In today’s era where electricity is closely related to our lives, it is imperative to follow regulations and install appropriate safety measures when using circuits. One of these safety measures is the use of self-controlled electrical switches, which can effectively protect electrical appliances from sudden power surges, thereby preventing accidents. Since the beginning of the 20th century, circuit breakers have been widely used as a safety measure to prevent overloads in electrical systems. With the advancement of technology, circuit breakers have continued to develop and advance, which has led to the development of miniature circuit breakers (MCBs) and molded case circuit breakers (MCCBs).
Miniature circuit breakers (MCBs) and molded case circuit breakers (MCCBs) belong to the category of electrical protection devices known as circuit breakers. They are the most common types of circuit breakers in AC power circuits in industrial plants, commercial buildings, residential electrical wiring equipment, and photovoltaic systems. Although they look similar, they are designed for different purposes and have unique features tailored to the specific requirements of electrical systems, such as construction, capacitance, tripping characteristics, and breaking capacity.
In this article, first, let us understand what the abbreviations MCB and MCCB stand for. Then we will understand their meanings in detail. Then, this article will discuss the differences between MCB and MCCB.
1. What is an MCB?
MCB is a compact circuit breaker designed for low voltage electrical equipment. They are commonly used in residential, light commercial and industrial environments to protect circuits and equipment from overloads and short circuits. MCB is characterized by its small size, easy installation, and ability to provide protection for a single circuit. It automatically opens the circuit to which it is connected when the current flowing through the circuit exceeds the predefined limit. We can manually turn this device on or off when necessary, just like a normal switch. It is easy to reset and does not need to be replaced.
In reality, these are time-delayed trip devices. Their operating time is controlled by the magnitude of the overcurrent flowing through it. Therefore, the device will function as long as the overload lasts for a longer period of time. An MCB will never react to transients such as motor starting currents or switching surges. Typically, these devices can operate in less than 2.5 milliseconds during a short circuit fault and between 2-120 seconds during an overload condition.
2. What is an MCCB?
MCCBs are large circuit breakers designed for higher current applications and are typically used in high-power installations such as industrial and commercial facilities. Unlike MCBs, MCCBs are usually adjustable, providing higher breaking capacity. They are housed in a molded case that provides insulation and protection. MCCBs are able to provide overload, short-circuit protection, and in some cases, ground fault protection.
MCCB has two constructions, one for overheating and the other for overcurrent. It has bimetallic contacts that expand easily with temperature changes. Under normal operating conditions, its contacts allow current to flow through the circuit. However, as the current exceeds the specified limit, the contacts heat up and expand until they open. Thus, the circuit is disconnected from the main power supply, protecting the equipment from damage.
Both MCBs and MCCBs interrupt the current flow when an abnormal condition is detected, playing a vital role in ensuring the safety and reliability of electrical systems. Electric installations require different types of protection, so MCBs and MCCBs must be chosen based on factors such as the application, rated current, and specific protection requirements.
3. Differences between MCB and MCCB
MCCB and MCB differ mainly in their capacity. MCBs are rated for less than 100 amperes, have a breaking rating of less than 18,000 amperes, and since they are intended for low voltage circuits, their tripping characteristics cannot be adjusted.
MCCBs, on the other hand, have adjustable tripping characteristics that provide precise protection. They are widely used in high voltage circuits and provide currents as high as 2,500 amps to as low as 10 amps as required, with interrupting ratings ranging from 10,000 to 200,000 amps, and can be used as the main circuit breaker for the entire system.
1). Breaking capacity
MCCBs have a higher breaking capacity than MCBs, which means they can handle larger short-circuit currents without damage. MCCBs can interrupt currents up to 100 kA, while MCBs can interrupt currents of 10 kA or less. While MCBs may have lower breaking capacities, ranging from a few thousand amperes to tens of thousands of amperes, they are sufficient for most home and light commercial applications, where fault currents tend to be lower and more manageable.
2). Size and construction
MCBs are smaller and more compact than MCCBs (e.g., 22 mm wide single-pole modules), reflecting the concentration of lower-rated load currents into more tightly packed internal structures. Concentrated resistor components or wound magnetic coils take full advantage of miniaturized space to provide core protection functions such as overload sensing and magnetic trip response. Suitable for space-constrained applications. MCCBs are larger, with heavy-duty construction including intermittent insulation housings, more rugged internal mechanisms, and components designed to manage higher energy loads, and are typically used in industrial environments with fewer space constraints.
3). Tripping characteristics
All circuit breakers will trip or open their contacts when an overload or short circuit fault is detected. However, the tripping characteristics differ between MCBs and MCCBs. The tripping curve of an MCB is very fast and steep. A slight overload of 120-150% of the rated current activates the magnetic tripping mechanism, resulting in an almost instantaneous trip within milliseconds. These tight tolerance bands combined with an ultra-fast response are designed to isolate downstream equipment faults very quickly before catastrophic faults propagate upstream.
In contrast, MCCBs prefer to provide a tolerant “coordination delay” measure. This prevents immediate tripping on starting current or motor surge transients, up to 8 times the rated value, with an adjustable time of 500ms or more. Only when the overload lasts more than 120% and the coordination time is delayed, the thermal or magnetic MCCB release will activate to open the contacts. The benefit is that unnecessary large motor shutdowns and load-starting current surges are avoided, allowing for more flexible protection against electrical faults.
4). Application scenarios
MCBs are typically used in residential and commercial environments, such as residential distribution panels, small commercial buildings, light industrial environments, etc. MCCBs are used in commercial and industrial environments that need to handle higher power and more complex systems, such as industrial machinery and equipment, motor control centers, large commercial buildings, utility substations, etc.
5). Manufacturing cost
Generally speaking, the cost of MCCB is 25% to 50% higher than the standard MCB model with the same rated current. This is due to the fact that the physical materials and components of MCCB are larger, it has higher grade conductors to handle higher currents, a more complex tripping mechanism, and the strong R&D and compliance testing behind it. All these factors make MCCB more expensive than MCB.
6). Maintenance and lifespan
MCCBs require regular detailed inspections and preventive maintenance, which are recommended every 3 to 5 years. Professionals will check the integrity of wiring and connections, proper contactor alignment, and any evidence of sustained overheating. MCBs are typically sealed, non-serviceable construction with no user-serviceable parts inside. Replacement rather than refurbishment is recommended near the expected equipment life of 10 to 15 years, depending on the operating environment. More severe installation conditions such as moisture, corrosive gases, or high temperatures will shorten the service life.
4. Devices used before circuit breakers
So, before the invention and widespread use of MCB and MCCB, what circuit protection devices or technologies did people use to ensure electrical safety? I will list some representative devices used in the industry before the emergence of MCB and MCCB.
1) Fuse box
In the early days of circuit protection, fuses were one of the most common methods of protection. Different circuits were fused in separate fuse boxes. Fuses are thin wires that melt when subjected to excessive current, interrupting the circuit and preventing overcurrent. However, fuses needed to be replaced after each operation, and they did not provide as fast a response as modern circuit breakers.
2) Air circuit breaker
Air circuit breakers use compressed air to extinguish arcs when a circuit is interrupted. Air circuit breakers are an improvement over oil circuit breakers in terms of environmental impact, but they still require manual operation and have limitations in terms of speed and reliability.
3) Magnetic circuit breaker
Magnetic circuit breakers use electromagnetic coils to trip in response to overcurrent. While they are more sensitive than some earlier technologies, they lack the compactness and efficiency of modern MCBs and MCCBs.
The transition of electrical controls to MCBs and MCCBs has brought several advantages, including faster response times, compact designs, adjustable settings, and the ability to reset the circuit breaker after tripping, making electrical installations safer and more controllable.
5. Conclusion
In conclusion, both MCB and MCCB are essential components in any electrical system, protecting users from electrical hazards and reducing the risk of using electrical appliances. The choice between the two also depends on the specific requirements of the application scenario. MCB is more suitable for low-voltage applications such as homes and offices, while MCCB is ideal for industrial and commercial applications with high electrical loads. When choosing between the two, it is important to consider factors such as rated current, tripping characteristics, and durability to ensure that the circuit breaker provides the necessary protection for electrical equipment and appliances.
Leave A Comment